Discussion about this post

User's avatar
The Man Behind the Screen's avatar

Wait, wait, wait.

Do you mean to tell me that a sitcom that was specifically made to cater to the younger sister of a major celebrity, which cast her in a bright green glow of perfection all in an effort to boost her own celebrity, resulted in conflict between her and the other girls on set?!

As the eldest of five siblings, three of whom are my sisters, I'm sure you can imagine my absolute and utter shock at this development.

Expand full comment
Kim A.'s avatar

Appreciate another entry in the tale, and your putting it all in context. Going by the 2008 comment I'm about a decade older than you, so I didn't watch any of these shows at the time. I was peripherally aware of them through glimpses when clicking through TV channels (remember that?) and TV Tropes references, but that's about it.

When I heard Schneider had fallen from grace, I expected it would be depressingly predictable sexual stuff, but interesting that it also apparently involved straight-up bullying his cast. Agreed that he failed in his duty of care there. Do I even dare ask how he wrote out Nikolas' character when she quit on the spot?

This kind of stuff is one more reason acting as a profession fascinates me so much. Imagine having to portray a genuine-seeming friendship on screen with someone who hates your guts. That's such a strange dynamic, haha.

Acting is also pretty much the only profession where we've decided we're going to allow children to work, even if that's usually a huge taboo in modern Western culture. There's a lot of other things in TV and film that are stylized, and I could imagine an alternate timeline where, say, the convention was for adult women to dub over all child roles, or for teenagers to play younger kids and everyone just going along with it. I guess that's basically what they do with twenty-somethings in teen dramas already, so just move it down a few age grades. Sure, it'd look weird to us now, but if that was the convention no one would bat an eye. Compare the theater. Trusting children with actual grown-up work involving actual grown-up money (sometimes a lot of it) is a big leap of faith.

"the show tapped into every child’s desire to be whisked away to a gorgeous and opulent private academy"

Now I wonder how the kids subjected to the tender mercies of the British elite school system would feel about that. In my case, I loved HP as a kid, but the boarding school fantasy never did much for me. It was fun to read about, but I'd have absolutely hated being sent away from my home and my mom to spend the entire year in a setting like that, no matter how glamorous. Also note how Rowling gave Harry such a comically crappy home life he'd never be inclined to miss it.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts